Jump To Page Section
1. Overview 2. Exclusion of Poor Familes 3. Marriage Penalties 4. Complexity 5. Solution I: Simplified EITC 6. Solution II: The Standard Credit 7. References
Overview Pages
Introduction Why We Need Family Benefits The Major Problems Fixing Family Benefits
Problems
Two Tiers of Welfare Marriage Penalties
Marginal Tax Rates Asinine Asset Tests
Administrative Burdens Over-Reliance on Tax Code
Programs
Child Tax Credit Earned Income Tax Credit
Head of Household CDCC
SNAP (Food Stamps) TANF
WIC Medicaid & CHIP
Bills
Family Security Act Build Back Better
Working Families Tax
Relief Act
End Child Poverty Act
SSI Restoration Act
Share Article

Follow

Page Color
Features of Family Benefits
Two Tiers of Welfare
By Jay Martin
The most effective anti-poverty programs deliberately exclude poor families.
(Income slider now moves in dollar increments)

X-Axis Range: $0–$50,000.
Y-Axis Range: $0–$7,000.

Power Users

Highlights
Loading

The principal family programs that exclude poor people are the child tax credit, the earned income tax credit, and the head of household filing status. Additionally, nonrefundable tax credits like the child and dependent care credit, as well as itemized deductions broadly, provide little to no benefit to poor people. Even the standard deduction, which ensures that poor people do not owe any income tax, provides less tax savings to poor people than it does to people with higher incomes.

The primary consequence of excluding poor people is to lessen the poverty reduction effects of welfare programs. Poverty, and in particular child poverty, is substantially higher than it would be if poor people were not excluded.

The exclusion of poor people is typically justified on the basis that it will encourage work.

No, some programs do not exclude poor people. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), for instance, are targeted at poor people. These programs, however, are far more paternalistic and stigmatizing: they require in-person or phone interviews, interrogations of income sources and spending patterns, work requirements, complicated benefit formulas, limitations on what the benefit can be spent on (unlike the EITC and CTC's cash benefit), and onerous restrictions on the amount of money that can be saved. See pages Administrative Burdens and Asinine Asset Tests for more.

Highlights
Loading

The principal family programs that exclude poor people are the child tax credit, the earned income tax credit, and the head of household filing status. Additionally, nonrefundable tax credits like the child and dependent care credit, as well as itemized deductions broadly, provide little to no benefit to poor people. Even the standard deduction, which ensures that poor people do not owe any income tax, provides less tax savings to poor people than it does to people with higher incomes.

The primary consequence of excluding poor people is to lessen the poverty reduction effects of welfare programs. Poverty, and in particular child poverty, is substantially higher than it would be if poor people were not excluded.

The exclusion of poor people is typically justified on the basis that it will encourage work.

No, some programs do not exclude poor people. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), for instance, are targeted at poor people. These programs, however, are far more paternalistic and stigmatizing: they require in-person or phone interviews, interrogations of income sources and spending patterns, work requirements, complicated benefit formulas, limitations on what the benefit can be spent on (unlike the EITC and CTC's cash benefit), and onerous restrictions on the amount of money that can be saved. See pages Administrative Burdens and Asinine Asset Tests for more.

J
A splendid little Substack newsletter
Covering economics, the welfare state, and more
Arrives right in your inbox, as if by magic
Click here for delectable insights

Notes

  1. ^ Note 1.
  2. ^ Note 2.
  3. ^ Note 3.
  4. ^ Note 4.
  5. ^ Note 5.

References

A Project by Jay Martin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
You are free to share, copy, and adapt the material for any purpose, including commercial purposes, so long as appropriate credit is given.