Jump To Page Section
1. Overview 2. HOH is Regressive 3. Marriage Penalties 4. Complexity 5. Solution 6. References
Overview Pages
Introduction Why We Need Family Benefits The Major Problems Fixing Family Benefits
Problems
Two Tiers of Welfare Marriage Penalties
Marginal Tax Rates Asinine Asset Tests
Administrative Burdens Over-Reliance on Tax Code
Programs
Child Tax Credit Earned Income Tax Credit
Head of Household CDCC
SNAP (Food Stamps) TANF
WIC Medicaid & CHIP
Bills
Family Security Act Build Back Better
Working Families Tax
Relief Act
End Child Poverty Act
SSI Restoration Act
Share Article

Follow

Page Color
Programs
The Head of Household Filing Status
By Jay Martin
The American obsession with convoluted & regressive benefits administered through the tax code.
I have .

Highlights
Loading

The head of household filing status is a family benefit for single parents who pay for more than half of their household expenses. It provides a larger standard deduction and preferential tax rates.

Yes, poor families are excluded from benefits. The HOH filing status does not provide any benefit to single parents who make less than the single standard deduction ($12,950 in 2022). When considered in conjunction with the child tax credit, HOH provides no benefit to single parents with one child with an income below $18,950, to single parents with two children with an income below $24,662, and to single parents with three children with an income below $29,662 (see "How do tax credits affect HOH?"). Furthermore, benefits for working class people are substantially smaller than those for parents with higher incomes (see "Is HOH regressive?").

Basically, yes. By-and-large the benefit increases with income. However, itemizing reduces HOH tax savings because much of HOH's benefit comes from its larger standard deduction. This means that, in practice, upper-middle income people (who mostly use the standard deduction) and the small proportion of high income people who use the standard deduction tend to reap the largest benefit from HOH. From their, high-income people who itemize receive about 40% of the max benefit, middle-class people receive between 22% and 76% of the max benefit, and low-income people receive very little benefit, especially when taking into account the child tax credit (see "How do tax credits affect HOH?").

Itemized deductions reduce the benefit of the head of household filing status.

Considering HOH in isolation exaggerates the tax savings received by low-and-working class single parents. This is because, at lower incomes, nonrefundable tax credits like the nonrefundable component of the child tax credit eliminate or reduce the additional taxes faced by single filers. A single parent with $15,000 in income, for instance, would owe $205 in taxes as a single filer and $0 as a head of household, nominally producing an HOH benefit of $205. However, as a single filer they could use $205 of a nonrefundable tax credit to reduce their taxes to $0, while as a head of household they could not use any of the credit, resulting in $0 in taxes under both filing statuses and thus no benefit from the HOH filing status.

Tax credits do not affect HOH savings at higher income levels.

Yes. When a head of household marries a singler filer or another head of household, the amount of tax they owe as joint filers is generally going to be higher than the sum of their individual taxes when they were not married.

Highlights
Loading

The head of household filing status is a family benefit for single parents who pay for more than half of their household expenses. It provides a larger standard deduction and preferential tax rates.

Yes, poor families are excluded from benefits. The HOH filing status does not provide any benefit to single parents who make less than the single standard deduction ($12,950 in 2022). When considered in conjunction with the child tax credit, HOH provides no benefit to single parents with one child with an income below $18,950, to single parents with two children with an income below $24,662, and to single parents with three children with an income below $29,662 (see "How do tax credits affect HOH?"). Furthermore, benefits for working class people are substantially smaller than those for parents with higher incomes (see "Is HOH regressive?").

Basically, yes. By-and-large the benefit increases with income. However, itemizing reduces HOH tax savings because much of HOH's benefit comes from its larger standard deduction. This means that, in practice, upper-middle income people (who largely use the standard deduction) and the small proportion of high income people who use the standard deduction tend to reap the largest benefit from HOH. From their, most high-income people (who itemize their deductions) receive about 40% of the max benefit, middle-class people receive about 22% of the max benefit, and low-income people receive very little benefit, especially when taking into account the child tax credit (see "How do tax credits affect HOH?").

Itemized deductions reduce the benefit of the head of household filing status.

Considering HOH in isolation exaggerates the tax savings received by low-and-working class single parents. This is because, at lower incomes, nonrefundable tax credits like the nonrefundable component of the child tax credit eliminate or reduce the additional taxes faced by single filers. A single parent with $15,000 in income, for instance, would owe $205 in taxes as a single filer and $0 as a head of household, nominally producing an HOH benefit of $205. However, as a single filer they could use $205 of a nonrefundable tax credit to reduce their taxes to $0, while as a head of household they could not use any of the credit, resulting in $0 in taxes under both filing statuses and thus no benefit from the HOH filing status after tax credits.

Tax credits do not affect HOH savings at higher income levels.

Yes. When a head of household marries a singler filer or another head of household, the amount of tax they owe as joint filers is generally going to be higher than the sum of their individual taxes when they were not married.

J
A splendid little Substack newsletter
Covering economics, the welfare state, and more
Arrives right in your inbox, as if by magic
Click here for delectable insights

Head of Household is Regressive

See also: Two Tiers of Welfare

Head of Household is Regressive

Head of Household Creates Marriage Penalties

See also: Marriage Penalties

Head of Household Creates Marriage Penalties


.

Notes

  1. ^ Note 1
  2. ^ Note 2
  3. ^ Note 3

References

A Project by Jay Martin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
You are free to share, copy, and adapt the material for any purpose, including commercial purposes, so long as appropriate credit is given.